The Perfect Margarita

The Perfect Margarita is just that… it’s perfect. It’s a recipe that took me a few years to finally get around to making, and I can’t believe it took me SO long. You’ll never guess the secret ingredient I add! 

The Perfect Margarita | cakenknife.com

Once upon a time, I was just a girl working in corporate marketing for a big industrial real estate company. Among all the chaos and craziness of that job, I happened to be on a team of insanely talented folks. It just so happens to be one of those folks that inspired me to make this margarita for you all. The perfect margarita… with a special ingredient you’ll NEVER guess.

Ok so it might have taken me a couple of years to finally get around to it, but here it is, alright?!

It was my boss’s boss (Larry) who turned me onto the secret ingredient in this margarita. Now, I bet you can’t guess what it is…

The Perfect Margarita | cakenknife.com

Go on, GUESS.

Nothing? No guesses?

The Perfect Margarita | cakenknife.com

It’s…. apple juice. 

Oh yea, you read that correctly. Apple juice.

Don’t run away! Please! It’s not as insane as it sounds!

When Larry told me his secret ingredient was apple juice, I looked at him like “hey, I’m onto you mister. You can’t fool me” (he happened to have a knack for sarcasm and I never could quite tell when he was joking or when he was sincerely pissed). Then I watched, in horror, as he added apple juice to a giant pitcher of margaritas. Seconds later, everyone else was lining up for them saying they were the one thing they always looked forward to at Larry’s house.

The Perfect Margarita | cakenknife.com

All that was going through my head was, ok, I gotta try this. These people are nuts.

Then I took a sip. Holy CRAP, that drink was good. I guzzled down more than a few that day (so professional, I know), and I haven’t had a margarita that’s beat it since.

The surprising thing? This margarita is not super sweet. It’s perfectly balanced, with just the right amount of acid, sweetness and tequila. It’ll knock you on your butt before you know it, but you’ll keep going back for more because it tastes so damn good.

The Perfect Margarita | cakenknife.com

All I can say is, thank you Larry for turning me onto the apple juice secret. You’re a gentleman and a scholar in my book, forever.

The Perfect Margarita

Yield: 1 cocktail

Prep Time:5 minutes

My margarita has a secret ingredient... apple juice! It might sound insane but trust me, it's AMAZING.

Ingredients:

  • 2 oz silver tequila
  • 1 oz orange juice
  • 1.5 oz lime juice
  • 1 oz apple juice
  • 1 oz agave
  • Garnish: salt, lime wedges

Directions:

  1. Rim a cocktail glass with salt. Set aside.
  2. Fill a shaker with ice. Add tequila, orange juice, lime juice, apple juice and agave. Shake well.
  3. Fill cocktail glass with ice.
  4. Strain margarita into glass.
  5. Serve with a lime wedge.
Yum

2 Responses to “The Perfect Margarita”

  1. Stephanie @ Sustaining the Powers — June 23, 2016 at 9:06 pm (#)

    Oh! We are going to have to have a margarita night! I’ll bring some of my signature margaritas and we can compete. 😉 My secret ingredient is olive juice! I’ve never had them with apple juice before. Sounds delicious!

    • Meghan B. — June 24, 2016 at 10:06 am (#)

      OK this HAS to happen!!! Olive juice?! I wanna try!